“He cheated on me,” she said when I walked in the door. We had planned on a nice quiet dinner between old friends, but I instantly realized I should have brought whisky rather than wine. I opened my arms and she filled them, and for a long time neither of us said a word.
“The only bright side, is that now I get to do it too.” She was whispering into the crook of my neck and our hug suddenly felt very different. I stepped back until I could look into her eyes. We had been resisting each other for years, and then just like that he made all our hesitation feel foolish. What was the point of us holding back if he was going to fuck it up anyway?
“Have you picked someone out yet?” I asked.
Her kiss was crushing. Her mouth was sweet, and this time rather than simply wrap our arms around one another they were put to the business of removing clothes. We left a trail of them in the hallway until we collapsed naked onto their bed, my mouth between her legs tasting her for the first time. Her pussy was wet and slippery as I explored her folds and bit her thighs. I had two fingers inside her as she clenched around me, and she was begging by the time my tongue found her clit.
When I finally moved up to her mouth, my hard cock dangerously close to the entrance of her cunt, she grabbed my hair and bit my lip.
“I want to do something that I never let him do,” she said. There was anger in her voice, and my cock was painfully hard at her words. “He always asked, and I said no. And now I want you to do it, just because.”
When I slid into her pussy I forgot everything. She was tight and hot, and our bodies were so fully entwined we felt like the same person. We ground our pelvises together, scratched our backs, and wrapped our legs into twisted limbs that would never be free.
“Please tell me it’s your ass,” I growled. “Please tell me you want me to fuck this ass.”
She was on her hands and knees a second later, pointing to the condoms and lube on her bedside table. I rolled one down, squirted some lube onto two fingers, and attacked her. I pushed her down onto her stomach as my fingers found her asshole, and she moaned and writhed and grunted beneath my weight.
“Do it,” she begged.
“He really never fucked you here?”
“No,” she moaned, pushing back against me.
“Tell me what you want.”
“I want you to fuck me!” she said.
“My ass, I want you to fuck my ass.”
“I want to hear you beg for it. I’m not sure I really believe you.” I was still teasing her with fingers, but my cock was pressed against her, and she was squirming uncontrollably.
“Please,” she moaned.
“Louder,” I told her. “Beg like it’s the only thing in the world you’ve ever wanted.”
“Please fuck me. Please fuck me up the ass. Oh god, I can’t stand it.”
I held her still as I positioned myself against her tiny hole, and it looked impossible. I gasped as I pushed against her, and when I finally watched the head of my cock enter her, I was close to crying. Inch by inch I pushed, and she never once stopped begging for more. By the time I was fully inside her I was in love, and I was never going to leave.
“Fuck, that’s amazing. Your cock feels so fucking good inside me.”
I started to move, and she started to push back, and by the time she reached a hand between her legs, we were both close to coming. She thrust back against me, as I watched my cock slide in and out of her, and it was perfect. Her ass was impossibly tight, but even more than the physical sensation was the deep and profound knowledge that his affair had nothing on ours. She was giving me something he never had, and that thought alone was enough to make me come. She screamed and moaned, and I grabbed her and thrust so hard we fell onto the bed in a fit of shaking bodies.
“Holy shit, I’m coming. I’m coming with your dick up my ass. Oh god, keep fucking me!”
“I’m coming too,” I moaned. “I’ve wanted this ass for too many years, and I’m going to fill you with everything I have.”
By the time we slowed down we were covered in sweat, the room smelled like an orgy, and we had smiles on our faces bigger than the arch in Washington Square Park. She kissed me between giggles, and I held her hands as I caught my breath. Nothing would ever be the same again.
“That was amazing,” I said.
“I don’t know why we waited.”